Powered by Blogger.

Does anyone in power REALLY care about Sea Gypsies?

Tuesday, November 20, 2012

The latest in the never ending saga of land for Sea Gypsies has reared its head again, this time at Koh Sireh, Tambon Rassada, Phuket, where a private ’investor’ has laid claim to land that has been used by Sea Gypsies for generations.

It is unbelievable and ironic, that government bodies in Thailand, both local and central can, on the one hand state the invaluable and essential tasks of preserving the Sea Gypsy culture and way of life and on the other hand allow greedy and unscrupulous business people to lay claim to land that has been home to Sea Gypsy communities for generations.

It has been proven, by Royal visits in 1958 and 1959 that the Sea Gypsy communities at Koh Sireh and Rawai were both thriving communities at that time and probably for many years previously. Surely therefore it can’t be so difficult to enforce what has been stated by central government so many times, that anyone claiming land rights, must first of all prove their ownership prior to the dates the Sea Gypsy Communities were established.

Nothing moves forward for the Sea Gypsies........
Their land, slowly but surely diminishes (The Rawai Sea Gypsy Community numbering over 2000 people are living on just 5% of the land they once occupied).

Their fishing rights are restricted to the point where it would be impossible to make a living in a safe manner.
Their austere living conditions ignored.

Their human rights?...........It’s doubtful they are considered having any!

These are the essential points which need to be addressed NOW! whilst you still have living, breathing communities....... or maybe it would be easier for all concerned to allow the Sea Gypsy Communities to disappear completely THEN spend millions of Baht building Culture Centres to show how Sea Gypsy life used to be!


A grand plan for the 'forgotten'.......
.......or an ideal place for homeless Sea Gypsies to beg!


The Culture Centre in building.

A memorial to the Sea Gypsies?



WAKE UP - AND ACT NOW.    

Read more...

Saturday, November 3, 2012


Sea Gypsies under siege from owners

The Phuket Provincial Court is facing a long series of lawsuits aimed at getting members of the Rawai Sea Gypsy village – the largest such village in Phuket – evicted from land claimed by a local businessman who bought the land four years ago.

Over 2,000 Sea Gypsy residents of the village could be affected by this action.

Businessman Piyawat Sangiamkul, who owns the Baan Raya Resort & Spa on Racha Yai Island, is the second person to claim a portion of the Sea Gypsy Land. The first was Suthep Nukdee, who won two cases against brothers-in-law Maren and Anan Bangjak, when they unwittingly signed a document which, it transpired was a lease, effectively losing their right of ownership of the land. The courts upheld the decision that the two men were leasing the land. 
The ‘lease’ was signed by way of a thumb print as neither men, 
like many of the Sea Gypsies can read or write.

A lawyer representing the villagers, Puwanark Buaniam has already lodged an appeal on behalf of Maren and Anan Bangjak and is awaiting a court date for the appeal.
Niran Yangpan, is the representative of the Sea Gypsy community and was at pains to point out that the village has been the home of Sea Gypsies for over 100 years.

Records show the Sea Gypsies were occupying the land for the past 100 years, but word of mouth indicates, the gypsies could have been resident there for 500 years.

Landowners claim they have deeds issued since 1971, 
however, there is photographic proof of HM the King visiting the village in 1959.

Mr. Piyawat claims he purchased the land at an Auction from the Legal Execution Department of the  Bank of Ayutthaya which handles auctions of property against defaulted loans.
Mr Piyawat also claims he didn’t know the land was occupied and didn’t make any inspection of the land prior to the purchase. 
In reality, Mr Piyawat was fully aware of the existence of the village and occupants as he had used their services for a number of years to transfer goods from Rawai to Raya Yai.

The Sea Gypsies of Rawai lead a simple existence, yet have centuries old traditions as a fishing community. This could all be lost due to greed and corruption and no-one in authority seems to care.

It doesn’t take a rocket scientist to figure out the value of the land in question and if the courts concede to this case with Mr Piyawat (of Raya Yai fame) it will open the flood gates for the other 6 landowners, effectively evicting the entire Gypsy Village.

The Sea Gypsies make no financial gains from the land, other than a handful of fish and handicraft stalls to help make ends meet and of course, a place to live for over 2,000 residents.

Previous governments have made ‘noises’ in support of the Gypsies, but do very little to help when it’s really needed.

Maybe it’s time HM the King paid another visit, if not to the land, then to the issue and settle the matter once and for all.

Support the The sea Gypsies, like us and become our friends and fans on facebook

Read more...

Bangkok Land Officials Swarm Phuket.............

Friday, November 2, 2012

but are they swarming the most important areas?.
No fewer than 366 officials have been allocated to investigate privately owned land along the border of the Marine National Park. They are all part of the ''Thai Pure Heart'' campaign were the Office of Public Sector Anti-Corruption, the Interior Ministry, the National Anti-Corruption Commission, the Department of Special Investigation, the Department of Natural Resources & Environment and the Agricultural Land Reform Office. The Officers will be split into 36 teams with 6 officers to each team and be allocated to specific areas by way of a lottery, presumably to ensure there is no collusion with the landowners in question.

Bangkok anti-corruption team (pictures from Phuket Wan)


With all these resources at hand, would it have been out of the question to allocate just one of the 36 teams to investigate the land entitlement of the Sea Gypsy Community in Rawai.

Land presently occupied – shown in red. Land previously occupied – shown in yellow.

In fact, I would go as far as to suggest, that in view of the fact that the questionable land entitlement by a handful of local business people, would affect upwards of 2,000 Sea Gypsy residents, that it should be No. 1 on their list of priorities.
Despite ‘noises’ being made by various Governments and Government Departments, to protect the Sea Gypsies, the whole issue, it would appear, has been filed in the ‘difficult tray’, in the hope that if it’s left there long enough, the problem will go away or be forgotten.
Regardless of the fact that the Sea Gypsies and their forefathers have lived in Thailand for many years, they were only recently given the opportunity to get a Thai ID-card and in that respect, 
a step towards recognition as Thai citizens.
One can assume, that it would have been very difficult, if not impossible, for the sea gypsies to have had even the slightest chance to have laid claim to the land on which they have lived for well over 100 years before becoming Thai citizens. Non-Thais are, as we all know not allowed to own land in Thailand.

Maybe it’s true to say that the Sea Gypsies of Thailand, have no claim to their land, their homes, their livelihoods or to their Basic Human Rights! Unless someone out there is prepared to fight their case.

Is General Surin the only one who cares?

Community Organizations Development Institute (CODI) President Gen Surin Pikulthong believes that the Government should officially consider that the areas where the Sea Gypsies are living are an integral part of Thailand instead of being considered a special cultural area for the ethnic minorities.
"If this is considered a special area, then there will be some relaxation in the short term, but, once the relaxation is over, then everything will return to the way it was. The sea gypsies will be back in trouble again," said Gen Surin.
He suggested that the government should adopt a policy officially recognising all Sea Gypsy communities in Thailand, and that they belong to the country so that they would be entitled to their basic rights.
 (MCOT online news)





Read more...

Bangkok post 2012 11 11

Wednesday, October 31, 2012

Extracts from BANGKOK POST Sea Gypsy article  published 11th November 2012

The Community Network for Political and Social Reform,  which encompasses ethnic groups nationwide, says there are 41 sea gypsy communities on the Andaman's shores with an estimated population of 17,400, and they are suffering under the conservation regulations, especially those of the National Parks, Wildlife and Plant Conservation Department.

( sea gypsies protesting for human rights in Bangkok )

It was a little more than 20 years ago that things started to change. One day Nui sailed to Koh Surin, where he was told by officials that he could not fish in the shallow waters any more because it was now a national park. If he insisted on fishing there, he would be arrested.

According to the Community Network for Political and Social Reform, 28 out of 41 sea gypsy communities face the threat of having their land seized, and it is almost impossible for them to stop it because those doing the land grabbing hold land right documents.

( Sea Gypsies protesting for human rights in Bangkok )

At Rawai beach, at least 10 sea gypsy families are being sued by private land owners. Nui's family is one of them, and he has vowed to fight to the end to keep the land he lives on, just as his ancestors did.

At Koh Phi Phi, a few hotels have already been built on sea gypsy cemeteries and at Lan Ta in Krabi province, the sea gypsies are being told to remove their loved ones' remains from Bor Nae cemetery or see them destroyed by land developers.

Maitree Jongkraijak, a leading member of the Community Network for Political and Social Reform, said the problems of the sea gypsies have grown over time and first received widespread public attention following the 2004 tsunami, which destroyed their homes and saw their ancestral land subject to land grabs.

``Sea gypsies do not have the concept of occupying and possessing things or land, and that is one reason why they have problems fighting claims to their land,'' said Mr Maitree.
``But what is clear in their case is that the present administration and regulations are very fixed and narrow -they do not embrace those who have different lifestyles, especially traditional ones that may be out of the context of the present administration and regulations. They just do not embrace diverse cultures and societies.''
Narumon Arunotai, a lead researcher at Chulalongkorn University's Social Research Institute, and vice-chairwoman of a subcommittee following up the progress of the cabinet resolution, said the principal problem concerning sea gypsies may be the public prejudice against them.
Ms Narumon agreed with Mr Maitree that sea gypsies have very different values and lifestyles. This has been reflected in land conflicts. Most people think of land as being owned by individuals, while sea gypsies think of it as communal. In fact, they hardly have a concept of possession, which is in keeping with the sufficiency economy theory.
Instead of learning from them, people view them as strange and try to compel them to become part of ``normal'' society.
Ms Narumon said such attitudes are wrong and people need to be more open to different cultures and a more diverse society.

The cabinet resolution, she said, is progress, since it acknowledges the sea gypsies' problems, which have at least been addressed at a policy level. Implementation is what is required now, she said.
``At least the cabinet resolution has shown that there is room to embrace others, although it may mean the creation of a special cultural zone to facilitate it,'' said Ms Narumon. ``I call it progress as it embraces the principle of coexistence. We live in the same world, so we must acknowledge others, not marginalise them.''

Read more...

For all to see.........



..............the Rawai sea gypsies truth.


Part 1
Double click to go full screen
Part 2
Double click to go full screen

Stacey Dooley, where are you now ?

Read more...

The Sea Gypsies versus the House of Shame

Tuesday, October 30, 2012


The Rawai Sea Gypsies have lived – uncontested – at their current beachfront location for at least three generation and probably much more.
It would appear that most of the problems for the Sea Gypsies and other poor minority groups, began following the 2004 Tsunami. Maybe unscrupulous business people along with corrupt land officials taking advantage of the Tsunami’s ensuing chaos.
They have already lost a large portion of their land east of the village, (edged in yellow in map below) to a businessman who claimed ownership of the land. Having taken the land from the Sea Gypsies, he is now the proud owner of a derelict, unfinished, unoccupied building, whilst the Sea Gypsies are forced into an ever decreasing area to live, amounting to just 5% of the land they once occupied.




To make matters worse, the businessman claiming ownership of the land, (marked in yellow) is in debt to his bank, using the land and unfinished buildings as collateral. The bank now has possession of the title deeds and has put the land and buildings up for sale.
The Rawai Sea Gypsies are not the only ones on Phuket fighting for their land.
Latest reports from our local newspapers show………
Some 2,000 families on Soi Kingkaew, in Rassada, were recently confronted with a similar threat to that of the Rawai Sea Gypsies.
Two other communities with PMOVE ( Peoples Movement ) membership fighting similar battles on the island include the "Community Behind Rama IX Park" in Phuket Town and the "Khok Tanode Community" in Chalong.
And just recently……
23 Villagers of Koh Racha Yai, Who have lived and worked on the island for generations, want to know why their request for land deeds was denied when similar requests on Koh Racha Yai, made by outside investors, were granted.
 At the end of the day it would appear that it all comes down to what happens behind these gates:



( house of Shame )


In 2003, Pongtorn Hiranyaburana, the Deputy Chief of the Phuket Provincial Land Titles Office, who was in the process of investigating the issuing of illegal land titles, was shot dead as he drove home from Phuket to Surat Thani.
His murderers were never found.

Recently, The National Anti-Corruption Commission has been asked to investigate the alleged involvement of a former Phuket Deputy Governor and a former Interior Permanent Secretary over unlawful land acquisitions on the island. Over 200 plots of land are currently being investigated.

Major General Dusadee Arayawuthi who is leading the investigation says he and his staff have been threatened several times since they began their enquiries.

The investigation of course revolves around Phuket Land Office and will no doubt move to higher departments if the enquiry is allowed to continue.

 In March 2012, the Chief of the Land Office declared that he ‘welcomed the investigations, as a deterrent against future abuses’.

‘future abuses’ is little consolation for those affected by past corruption.




Are these poor people just victims of high ranking crooks and criminals, through
deception and corruption within Government Offices?


 
Surely, it isn’t too much to ask, that those involved in wrong doings are held responsible.
For the Sea Gypsies of Rawai, a full investigation should take place on all land east of Rawai Pier, with particular reference to land title deeds issued in 1970 and 1971.

The Sea Gypsies of Rawai, number over 2000 residents and are just a part of the 10,000 Sea Gypsies estimated to be living in Phuket and around the Andaman Sea.
Their human rights have been ignored for long enough.

Does Thailand, soon to entering the Asean Treaty, wish to be
compared with Myanmar in their treatment of human rights?

There are so many positives could come from the Sea Gypsy issue:

The Government could be seen to be helping them by ensuring they have Government water,  individual electricity supply and adequate drainage and sewage facilities.

The ‘questionable’ land, east of the village, should be returned to the Sea Gypsies.
The land currently occupied by the Sea Gypsies along with the ‘questionable’ land, should be allocated officially as Sea Gypsy land under the Community Chanote scheme, created under the former Democrat government of Abhisit Vejjajiva. It allows communities to live on the land and use it for agriculture, but does not allow the land to be sold.

The trades and handicrafts of the Sea Gypsies should be encouraged, as it is a unique heritage and in danger of disappearing.

The entire area could be proposed as a UNESCO heritage site, under sections,

(iii) to bear a unique or at least exceptional testimony to a cultural tradition or to a civilization which is living or which has disappeared.

(vi) to be an outstanding example of a traditional human settlement, land-use, or sea-use which is representative of a culture (or cultures), or human interaction with the environment especially when it has become vulnerable under the impact of irreversible change.

Post Script: For whatever misdemeanors have taken place in the past, there is an opportunity here for the Government to resolve the situation, by re-claiming the waterfront land (edged in yellow) and returning it, along with their present domicile to the Sea Gypsy Community, (under the Community Chanote Scheme) declaring the entire gypsy land for sea gypsy use in  pursuance of their unique way of life.

We appeal to our Government, our Land Officials and to our friends in Thailand and beyond to give a thought to and help the Sea Gypsies (Moken), before it’s too late.

Read more...

A Royal visit

Monday, October 29, 2012


 .............to Rawai Sea Gypsy Village.

It has been stated, by high ranking officials of past and present Administrations that  if no 
one can present a Land Title Deed dated previous to when the
 Rawai Sea Gypsy Village was established then the land should 
belong to the Sea Gypsies of Rawai.

As far as we know, NONE of the " alleged landowners " on ANY stretch of Rawai beach
east of Rawai landing pier have presented land title deeds dated earlier then 1971.

Well, what can we say,
God Save H M the King.


                             
This movie was filmed in May 1959.

Read more...

  © Blogger template On The Road by Ourblogtemplates.com 2009

Back to TOP